I ca n’t estimate out who , on the button , Amazon ’s Halo Bandis project for . The covert - gratis band works in the background to track your action and sleep , and it also has microphone to heed in on your conversations and analyze your tone . There is some appeal to a screen - free wear that can cut down the distractions in your life while also give you useful wellness datum . Whoopdoes this well . But Halo Band is not a very good fitness tracker , and its two other flagship features require you to use your phone , picture the screen - free matter pretty moot . And making you palpate pretty awful in the cognitive operation .
After a few weeks of wearing the Halo Band to track my sopor and activity , eavesdrop on my conversation , and quantify my body fat , I have occur to the conclusion that this is a fittingness banding for no one .
Amazon Halo Band
Photo: Caitlin McGarry/Gizmodo
What is it ?
Amazon ’s first wearable equipment
cost
Photo: Caitlin McGarry/Gizmodo
$ 100 , plus $ 4 / calendar month subscription after the first 6 months
Like
Comfortable for all - daytime wear , a good selection of workout videos if you do n’t want to devote for a separate on - demand fitness subscription , tone analytic thinking is precise
Photo: Caitlin McGarry/Gizmodo
Do n’t like
Body fatty estimator seems inaccurate and also not helpful or actuate ; action stop arrangement is opaque ; if you ’re gon na put microphone in a wearable equipment at least make them utilitarian
The $ 100 Halo Band has three flagship feature film : activity - tracking , step analytic thinking , and physical structure rich measurements . I ’ll plunk into the latter two , which are bizarre at best and problematic at worst , in a second , but first I wanted to figure out if Amazon ’s first wearable was up to at its first job : monitoring movement and rest .
Photo: Caitlin McGarry/Gizmodo
The Halo Band prompt me of old Fitbits in that it ’s project to be totally unnoticeable . But where other generations of Fitbit bands excelled at track your heart rate and your activeness without much intercession , Amazon ’s wearable is so basic as to be almost useless . The band ’s built - in optical meat rate sensor and accelerometer chug along in the background to lumber your usage , so you do n’t have to manually start a exercise . But where Fitbit ’s motorcar - trailing feature can differentiate between different types of workouts , Amazon ’s band can only pinpoint whether you ’re walking , run , or doing some generic natural process that gets your heart pace pumping . It then score that activity with full stop that are based on recommendation from the American Heart Association . Amazon articulate exploiter should purpose for 150 dot per week . You ’re supposed to experiment with activeness , both on your own and using “ labs ” from third - political party married person like Orangetheory Fitness or Aaptiv , to see which type of workouts grade the most points .
The research laboratory are essentially workout video recording , which are hunky-dory to near bet on which partner is offering them . ( I personally find Aaptiv ’s audio - guided workouts purposeless because I need to see poses demonstrated , but some citizenry like them . ) To boost your activeness point , you could enrol in a program — say , a four - hebdomad yoga course — and receive monitor that you schedule ahead of fourth dimension to really take the division . you could also take workout course a la carte , and filter by exercise types — cardio , outdoor , strong suit , and yoga — class length , or which service they ’re offer on .
Gamifying exercise can be effective , and being able to access a miscellany of workouts through the app is useful if you do n’t want to blast out for a disjoined on - demand physical exertion cyclosis service . But the weekly stage system is pathetic . I ’m an combat-ready person who easy crystalize the recommend 150 points per workweek while wearing the dance orchestra , but that did n’t evidence me anything about my warmheartedness wellness or fittingness point . And torture up points is n’t as mentally satisfying as , say , vanquish your Fitbit friends in a day-to-day footstep challenge or close down the Apple Watch ’s action , move , and stand rings every sidereal day .
Photo: Caitlin McGarry/Gizmodo
Aside from award you point , the Halo Band logs your middle rate , step enumeration , calorie burn during a exercise . I logged a 3 - Swedish mile run on both the Apple Watch Series 6 and the Halo Band , and my average pump was in line for both ( 181 bpm for the Apple Watch and 177 bpm on the Halo Band ) but the calorie burn was wildly off—495 calories for Halo Band and 298 active kilocalorie burn up on the Apple Watch . You also wo n’t see mileage , footstep , or anything deeper than time spent doing light , restrained , and intense activity in the Halo Band app after working out . And block logging other type of exercising — a 45 - mo Peloton ride net me 88 points in the Halo Band app , but looking back through my weekly logs , I only know what type of exercise I was doing that mean solar day because I tracked the class on the Apple Watch , too .
Amazon allege the Halo Band is designed to help you understand and improve your health and physical fitness , but the point system is just too obtuse to be utilitarian .
I also recover the Halo Band ’s power to listen to your conversation and analyze the tone of your voice to be fundamentally useless . Letting a equipment heed to you , at random sampling minutes of your conversations , is just patently creepy . We make that tradeoff with voice - activated assistant like Alexa because we get something utile in retort — we might not love an always - on microphone , but if an assistant can immediately respond our every question or execute a command on demand , we ’ve together with decided as a gild that the bizarreness is passable . The Halo Band ’s tone analysis is not as useful as Alexa . Despite what Amazon may think , most mass know on the nose how they sound when they talk .
To set up tone analysis , you train the Halo Band to realise your voice by read aloud a fistful of passing from classical novel . The lot has two built - in mike and an LED spark that dash green when it activates to start listening to you . I ’ve got ta be honest : People do not love when you tell them your fitness tracker has mike . My married man asked that I turn it off , even after I told him that the banding only mind for my spokesperson and that the recordings are n’t stored after they ’re analyzed on - machine .
There was nothing dysphemistic ( to me ) in the Halo Band ’s analysis , and at no point did I retrieve that the equipment slip my tone due to me being a fair sex . It was usually accurate , in fact — at least when I could think the conversations that the dance orchestra timestamped and categorize . I just did n’t find it utilitarian . For instance , on Jan. 6 , as a fierce rebellion was taking place in our nation ’s capital , the Halo Band distinguish me I fathom “ foiled , ” “ skeptical , ” and “ pitiful ” in the hours follow the attempted coup . Well , yes . On twenty-four hour period that were less pregnant with emotion , I ordinarily voice “ happy ” or “ amuse . ” Sometimes I was “ restrained ” or “ annoyed . ” You ca n’t listen to the snippets that the Halo Band collects , because the gimmick does n’t store them — which is good!—but sometimes I would look back on a twenty-four hours ’s worth of data and mean , “ I have no thought who I was utter to at 1:35 p.m. or what I was disappointed about . ”
start the feature also drains your battery animation importantly . Amazon suppose Halo Band can last up to a week on a direction , and that dwindles to about 2.5 days with the tone psychoanalysis feature turned on . It is dead not worth the tradeoff unless you are truly struggling to figure out how you arrive across to other people .
The Halo Band ’s organic structure fat analytic thinking is another feature that made me imagine : Who is this for ? The body fatness scanner , which requires you to take a serial of photos of yourself clad in what is essentially underwear ( I wore bicycle shorts and a sports brassiere ) , estimates what per centum of your organic structure is fat . Amazon say body fat percentage is a more accurate indicator of your overall wellness than a metric liked BMI ( Body Mass Index ) , which can categorize an fantastically mesomorphic person as corpulent .
But this tool is … unearthly , at best , not to mention inaccurate from what I could enjoin , and I ask it would be profoundly problematic for those who have eubstance dysmorphia or have a history of eating disorder . We are in the midst of a pandemic and I live on in Los Angeles , the covid majuscule of the U.S. , so I did not seek out a aesculapian exam to equate Halo Band ’s analysis with calipers or a Bod Bot . I do have a Withings Body Cardio smart scale leaf , which uses a bioelectrical electrical resistance sensor to estimate body fat , and I ramble from 27 - 32 % on that scale . The Halo Band pegs me nigher to 40 % adipose tissue , which as a petite , very participating woman , does n’t sound all that precise . And even if it is precise , that does n’t really tell me anything . sure eccentric of fat , and where you carry it , say more about your health than simply how much productive you have . Halo Band does n’t break up any of that down for you , so all you ’re go out with is a weird model of yourself ( which , in my fount , was mold nothing like me ) and a slider tool that lets you consider what your body would look like at 50 % body fat and 13 % . Apparently if I could pare myself down to almost nothing , I would at long last have a six - plurality . Cool .
Like most human beings , I have been both small and heavy than I am now , and I know for a fact that I would bet nothing like the three - dimensional human body in the Halo Band app . But some people might expect at that figure and haunt over it . It ’s not helpful or informative , and might actively be harmful . And for what ?
Plus , your images are sent to the swarm for analytic thinking . That add together a tenuous ick factor . Amazon recommend that you not discase down fully to do the scan — a physical body - agree pair of short and a bra will answer — and that you only take one every two hebdomad , but still . It ’s eldritch . You have the option to store your most naked scan in Amazon ’s cloud if you want a record of have your trunk change over time , but , uh … no give thanks you .
And that impart me to why the Halo Band is such a eccentric gimmick . Amazon does n’t want you to look at your wrist . There is no screen , and the dance band does not oscillate . And yet it expects you to look at this improbably specific vocal analytic thinking on your telephone and reflect on how you sound , and it expects you to take private exposure of yourself to reflect on how fat you are . It ’s trespassing . I ’m not indisputable it ’s helpful . And I did n’t come up it motivating in the svelte . A physical fitness tracker should make you desire to make your end , not make you feel like shit .
README
A show - destitute fitness tracker is promising , but this ai n’t it .
The body blubber scanner and timbre analysis are uninspiring at best and might even make you feel big about yourself .
The Halo Band ’s action point system is n’t very motive .
you could decidedly witness a more capable seaworthiness tracker for the price .
Fitness TrackersHaloWearable reckoner
Daily Newsletter
Get the better technical school , science , and culture tidings in your inbox daily .
News from the future , delivered to your present tense .
You May Also Like
